This homemade Cherry Cheesecake Ice Cream has all the flavors with its creamy ice cream, graham crackers, and a sweet and tangy cherry ribbon swirled throughout!
Combine the pitted cherries, water, ¼ cup sugar, lemon juice and zest into a medium saucepan.
Allow the cherries to cook over medium heat until they start to break down, and the liquid begins to thicken. You might need to help break the cherries up with a potato masher.
Allow the sauce to cool while you make the ice cream base.
Cheesecake Ice Cream
Bring the cream cheese to room temperature.
Combine all the base ingredients, whole milk, heavy cream, cream cheese, and 1 cup sugar in a food processor or blender and blend until smooth.
Place the mixture into the fridge to allow it to cool about 4 hours. You do not want to proceed until the mixture is cool.
To Make Cherry Cheesecake Ice Cream
In an Ice Cream Maker
Process the cheesecake ice cream base in an ice cream maker until the cheesecake ice cream is almost set.
Sprinkle in the graham crackers and cherry sauce until it is swirled in.
Transfer the ice cream to a freezer-safe container until solid.
For No-Churn
Layer the ice cream base, cherry sauce, and graham cracker pieces into a freezer-safe container
Line the top with plastic wrap touching the surface and freeze until solid, usually overnight.
Notes
Don’t use 2% or low-fat milk or cream for this recipe, it contains a lot more water, and it can cause this ice cream to become icier.
Make sure your cream cheese is at room temperature before you blend the ice cream base together. This step will help ensure you get the smoothest results.
Dairy-free? This particular recipe is not dairy-free. However, I have had luck getting good results using my dairy-free vanilla ice cream recipe and adding 8oz of a dairy-free/lactose-free cream cheese substitute and used that as the base. Once I have that, then I add in the cherry sauce and graham crackers for the cherry cheesecake ice cream.